
In an email with a friend the other day, the topic of once-loved movies came up, and I got to thinking about the movies I thought were wonderful when I was between seven and twelve or so, but which turned out to be grave viewing errors while in my twenties.
We all have these landmines, I suspect. Small pockets of magical or hilarious viewing experiences of our childhood, ruined by re-watching through more mature eyes. Where there were once nice memories of the past, now we have soiled and disappointing adult experiences. Such revisited childish loves serve only to taint the enjoyment of the past, and make us question the judgment of our younger selves. These are joys that we never should have attempted to recapture.
Here are the top ten childhood films that I regret having seen a-new:10.
The Bay Boy (1984)
This was a cute little Canadian-American (like the new construction?) kid’s first big break. You may have heard of him: Kiefer Sutherland? Remember him?
Anyway, with a brain filled with stories about how my dad’s family knew Donald Sutherland’s family when they were teenagers (both grew up around Bridgewater- it’s a fact!), I was a huge fan of this clan. Frankly, if given the choice between an instant PhD degree (no strings attached), or an hour in a room alone with Donald Sutherland, I may still choose the latter…
However, this film… What can I say? For those of you who have never heard of it, it is the very rural, very Canadian story of a young man coming to age in Nova Scotia during the 30s, and trying to decide between a life in the Church or girls and their various delights. When I was a pre-teen I though Kiefer was about as loveable as they came, and that this film, being one of only a handful that even come close to dealing with rural-Maritime childhood, spoke directly to me.
It has not aged well. The story is as threadbare as the ever-present woolen costumes, and the melodramatics do become a bit much. Further, the obligatory priest-coming-on-to-the-altar-boy certainly doesn’t seem like a daring or innovative idea anymore… It just seems sad.
Is it still better than like 90% of teenager films made in the US today? Hell, yes! But this still doesn’t say much in its defense. (Try 1999’s
New Waterford Girl, instead.)
9.
International Velvet (1978)
I admit it: I love Anthony Hopkins. Baked, boiled, fried, or raw, this man is a wonder to behold in pretty near any horrible piece he’s been conned into doing. I also admit that, as most girls around nine, I loved horses…
Put them together, and you get a pretty mediocre film, but one which, in retrospect, I couldn’t help falling for. When they made this movie the year I was born, they saw me coming. Those producers knew what they were doing when they put a young girl on a horse and filmed it for two hours. And they knew exactly who their audience was. And I went for it.
All I can say is that this movie makes me very happy the Tony sobered up and started to read scripts before signing on to do them.
8.
Mannequin (1987)
Here’s a line never before admitted on this blog, but I am not ashamed to now say it:
Meshach Taylor is a genius! There, I said it. It needed to be said. He is the one thing I remember fondly from this dog of a picture.
Hang your head in shame, Kim Catrall. Aside from Pierre Trudeau, this is probably the worse thing you’ve ever done.
7.
Labyrinth (1986)
OK, I will admit that, in some moods, this movie does still appeal to me, but in a way that is far from the thrill I used to get from it. David Bowie is still pretty enjoyable, but watching Jennifer Connelly’s stinkerific performance in this makes me think
A Beautiful Mind (2001) may have been a miracle of divine intervention.
In Ludo’s words, her acting does, indeed, “
SMELL BAD!”
6.
Turner and Hooch (1989)
Oh, my, did I once think Tom Hanks was amusing! And when he was threatening a slobbery dog with a handgun in that shrill and tumor-inducing yell of his, I thought he was a comic genius. And then when he and Hooch bond, and then the dog valiantly gave up his life for Turner… Oh, how I cried.
Now how I yawn. And scoff. And roll my eyes… Pretty much anything but laugh or cry.
And then I picture Hanks going down in front of a bullet instead of the poor dog.
5.
The Princess Bride (1987)
My first viewing experience of this film was ideal: I was home sick from school and my mom rented this for me to watch-
JUST LIKE THE KID IN THE FILM! However, since a friend bought this DVD for me a few years ago as a gift, I seem to only remember the nausea.
This movie once seemed like a living fairy tale to me, with its bright colour scheme and giant rats. Now all I can see is the pre-fab plot. For me, the only bright spot in this thing is the appearance of one of my Idols: Mandy Patinkin. And one of my lesser idols: Wallace Shawn.
Cary Elwes, however, may be the worst hero ever casted, anywhere, and it is hard to picture him inspiring love in anyone.
INCONCEIVABLE, in fact!
Sad.
Very sad.
4.
The Goonies (1985)
I first watched this film in about the third or fourth grade. My teacher rented a copy for us for our Christmas party (along with the terrifying, wet-pants-inducing
Return to Oz (1985), about which I still have horrible nightmares), and sitting there in the dark in the middle of the room which usually housed only torturous math tests and hand-writing lessons, it seemed like a dream. To my young eyes it was adventurous, enormous and very funny.
Now all I notice about it is the fact that there isn’t one line in the entire thing that isn’t screamed at the top of pre-adolescent lungs, and that the whole steaming pile makes my ears bleed.
What the hell was I thinking?
3.
The Outsiders (1983)
When I was a silly and slightly pathetic 12-year-old girl, S.E. Hinton’s tear-soaked tale of teen angst and social injustice seemed to me to be a junior version of
Catcher in the Rye. When Pony Boy and his pals jumped to the big screen, I was as enamored with this film in a big way. The romance, the pathos, the greasy hair… So much to love.
However, when I caught this film on late night TV a few years back, thinking “Hey- why not re-live a bit of my youth?” I got a really good answer why I shouldn’t try to re-live my youth… For one thing- really, really,
really amateurish acting. For another thing- really, really,
really, corny script.
Oh well- not everything green is gold. Some green is just under-ripe.
2.
Making Mr. Right (1987)
In my school-girl ideas of romance, this seemed pretty sweet. It also seemed pretty funny. However, if you see this pop up on TBS, as it does almost every day, avoid it.
Do yourself and John Malkovich a favour and forget you ever heard of it.
1.
Spaceballs (1987)
This film is the granddaddy of twenty-something disappointment. When I was ten or so, I thought that this movie was the funniest thing ever made. Mel Brooks’ take on
Star Wars?!? That has got to be comedy gold, right?
Oh my
LORD, that was wrong! So
very wrong. So wrong that I wanted to scratch my own eyeballs out to get away from it… puns (so very many puns), and the movie joke equivalents to some old, tipsy uncle getting you to pull his finger at Thanksgiving. This movie is trash, pure and simple. Not even enjoyable trash…
Just plain trash.
Not funny. Not clever. Not even good satire. It makes me ashamed.
Finally, a Dishonorable Mention:
Walk Like a Man (1987). With all due respect to Howie Mandel, this thing is a
crime against humanity.
These were movies I distinctly remember liking or even
loving in my pre-teen years… But ones that I probably couldn’t even stand to watch in their entirety now. Something in me died when I realized that, and I don’t want the same thing to happen to you. Avoid your childhood treasures like the plague, and guard those precious memories.
Little Holly, I am so very sorry for you… and, frankly, a little disgusted with you, as well.